A Methodology for Optimum Selection of Solid Modeling Software

Authors

  • Gül E. Okudan The Pennsylvania State University

Abstract

This study proposes a methodology that would enable a design educator or a design practitioner to optimally select a solid modeling software (solid modeler) for varying objectives. Specifically, tasks accomplished to propose the methodology include: 1) reviewing past literature to compile the criteria used for selecting solid modelers, 2) preliminary comparison of a number of solid modelers on established criteria, 3) running designed experiments for comparing the user performance on predetermined solid modeling functions, and 4) compiling the experience gained as a generic methodology. The application was completed over a two-year period while a systematic selection process was undertaken at The Pennsylvania State University (Penn State). This paper documents the entire selection process including the student design performance data collected. The set of outcomes of the study is expected to aid companies and design educators in making solid modeler selection decisions.

Downloads

Issue

Vol. 68 No. 3 (2004): Autumn

Section

Feature Articles

License

By submitting a manuscript, the authors agree that the copyright for their article is transferred to the publisher if and when their article is accepted for publication. The author retains rights to the fair use of the paper, such as in teaching and other nonprofit uses. Membership in EDGD-ASEE does not influence acceptance of papers.

Material submitted should not have been published elsewhere and not be under consideration by another publication.